This is an interesting Labour Court victory for a Makro manager who lost his job over just three pies bought for R7 each.

This is an interesting Labour Court victory for a Makro manager who lost his job over just three pies bought for R7 each.
0
(0)

The case involved Sello Daniel Mashabela, a manager at Makro’s Alberton branch, who has now won his job back after the Labour Court ruled that his dismissal was unfair.

What happened?

Piemans Steak & Kidney (pre Baked) | Agrimark

  • On 10 April 2023, Mashabela bought three pies at R7 each, paying R21.
  • The normal price was R283.95 for a box of 12 pies.
  • The individual pies scanned at R7 because an old product code was still active on Makro’s till system.
  • A fellow manager had told him the pies were on special.
  • Makro accused him of dishonesty and dismissed him in July 2023.

Why did the Labour Court overturn his dismissal?

Acting Judge M H Mhambi found several problems with Makro’s case:

  1. No proof of dishonesty: Makro failed to prove that Mashabela knew the price was incorrect when he bought the pies.
  2. The till accepted the price: He paid openly, received a till slip and passed through security.
  3. Management was also confused: The manager who told him about the markdown also bought pies at the same price.
  4. The pricing error was longstanding: Individual sales at R7 had apparently been taking place for months.
  5. The CCMA made a mistake: It failed to properly consider Mashabela’s individual circumstances and treated the employees as though they had all acted with the same intention.

The judge did, however, criticise Mashabela for failing to report the pricing problem once he became aware of it.

But that was not the misconduct he had been charged with.IOL+1

What happens now?

Reinstatement ordered

The Labour Court ordered Makro to:

  • Reinstate Mashabela immediately.
  • Return him to his former position as Sales Manager: General Merchandise, or a substantially similar position.
  • Restore his employment conditions to at least their previous level.

He was given seven days from the court order to report for duty.

Importantly, he was not awarded back pay, because he had not asked the court for it.

The judgment was delivered on 12 November 2026.SAFLII+1

My take: A lesson for South African employers

This case highlights an important principle of South African labour law:

An employer cannot simply dismiss someone because their behaviour looks suspicious. It must prove the actual misconduct charged.

There is a difference between making a careless purchasing decision and deliberately stealing from your employer.

Makro may have had legitimate concerns about its stock controls, but the court found that it had failed to prove dishonesty in this particular case.

And perhaps the biggest lesson: employers must get their own pricing systems and disciplinary procedures right before blaming employees for mistakes.

Read the actual Labour Court judgment: Mashabela v CCMA and Others – 2026 ZALCJHB 422.

How was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Share on social media!

Leave a Reply